I have recently
become aware of an exciting development in the world of Newtonian physics - one
that hails from the Science and Engineering labs of the Hundred Acre Wood. This discovery was prompted by observation of
the creature Gophur, a mammalian troglodyte.
Gravity appears
to affect Gophur differently than matter as we know it. The equation
X = X0 + V0 t + 1/2 (a) t2
…gives the distance an object falls as a function of
time, assuming a constant acceleration due to gravity. On numerous occasions, though, we can see
Gophur fall at variable rates: a continual problem for burrowing mammals in the
region is the danger of being knocked down one's hole, one he faces on a
regular basis. Gophur is a precise creature,
planning his projects down to an eighth of an inch (6:05). Although his tunnel system is not
symmetrical, it would beg the question to assume he makes his entrances (the
same shafts down which he falls) in an irregular fashion. Still, the fact remains that some of his
falls are short (three seconds - 0:58) while others improbably long (up to seventeen - 2:40).
One of the
biggest difficulties in understanding the relationship physics has with the
characters in the hundred acre wood is the lack of regular measurements. The show is animated, making some assumptions
completely ludicrous. For example, we
can see that Owl is superior in stature to both Pooh and Tigger, although in
nature we can clearly see this is not the case.
The issue here is rooted in the characters being stuffed animals, making
Christopher Robin - a human - our best frame of reference.
Given that he is
a young male in mid-20th century England, born after WWI but before WWII (A.A.
Milne’s son Christopher Robin was born in 1920), and living in the country, we
can assume he is fairly healthy. The
books were published in 1926, so let us presume the Christopher Robin in the
stories is 6 years old. The median
height for 6 year old children around this time was about 100 cm (pg. 172). C.R. seems pretty tall, so we’ll put him in
the top 90th percentile, or 120 cm. We
can see that Gophur comes up to about half his height, let's round off his
stature to 60 cm (2 ft).
In the episode
“Light’s Out”, we’re fortunate enough to see the entrance to one of Gophur’s
holes from the bottom (2:30). Counting the rungs on the ladder leading from
the bottom to the mouth of the hole (8, give or take) and noting from a scene
at the top of the hole that Gophur (irrationally) put the rungs of his ladders
about one Gophurheight apart, this puts the depth
of the hole around 16 feet. (The Gophurheight is a new unit of mine - SI verification pending). One might
presume, then, that he falls (or can fall) at a rate of one Gophurheight/second
- unfortunately he doesn't fall down this one, so we can’t get a concurrent
fall time and fall length. However, this
scene is also reveals that the hole itself is not perfectly vertical - it runs
in segmented sections at an overall slope of about -10/1. Finally, let us note that there is no way to
confirm the shot is from the bottom of Gophur’s hole. This thought is trivial in comparison to the
fact that we now know Gophur, whom we thought to be a logical engineer, appears
to make his tunnels any which way. In
the words of Socrates, “...all I know is that I know nothing.”
But before we lament
the lack of standard units in the hundred acre wood (which is a shame, as they’re
British and should use the imperial system), we need to comment on a fault of this
analysis thus far: we have limited our observations to Gophur and the physics
surrounding him. Perhaps, however, these
laws are universal. In one instance,
Gophur emerged from the ground just in time for Rabbit to fall into his new
exit, the fall lasting about 12 seconds (0:56). The kinematic equation above, substituting
height for X and -9.81 m/s2 would simplify to
Fall height = -4.905 m/s2 (12s)2 = 706 m
…meaning Rabbit fell 706 meters.
A similar equation can give us the speed at which he landed:
Vfinal = Vinitial + A(t)
We know Vinitial was 0 m/s (V referring to his vertical
velocity), A = -9.81 m/s2, and t = 12, so
Vfinal = -9.81 m/s2 (12s) = 177.7
m/s
This is a velocity no rabbit is physiologically
prepared for. His speed is such that,
though not impossible, it is extremely unlikely he should survive hitting the
ground. But clearly he did, because
moments later we see Rabbit rejoin the group, no worse for the wear. There was some elapsed time (the group was
playing a ball game, and there was enough time to change batters), but it is
clear he has not been gone very long.
Perhaps there is
one more consideration to make before throwing calculations around: the first
principle of cartoon physics states that the normal force from the ground
continues to act on an object leaving the ground, until such a time as the lack
of terra firma is observed. In other
words, a sentient being leaving the edge of a precipice will continue in their
initial direction without downward acceleration (though slowing in speed) until
shortly after becoming aware of their predicament. The principle allows for 1 to 2 seconds of
comical panic before Newtonian physics resumes.
This is
significant, as it implies that the laws of physics are subject to change based
on observation not just at the particle level (see: double slit experiment) but
for whole bodies.
For instance,
Gophur once tested the depth of a cavern by casting a stone down it. Shortly thereafter, he leapt down the hole
with gusto. The stone fell for seven
seconds, but Gophur's fall lasted less than three (7:35). It is pertinent to note that Gophur did not
push himself downward: he jumped up, over the mouth of the hole, and fell down
it, so the force of gravity acting on he and the stone should have generated an
equal amount of acceleration, and thereby identical fall times.
This situation raises
an obvious question: did the pebble fall naturally because it has no
consciousness, and cannot observe its falling state? If the first principle of cartoon physics
applies only to conscious beings, perhaps a falling trajectory has some sort of
wave form which, when observed, dissolves into a single path of travel (like a
light wave into a photon - again, double slit experiment). There is troubling evidence on this notion,
however: on one occasion, rabbit lends pooh honey, a single drop at first and then
a whole downpour. The single drop fell
(into a jar no more than a foot deep) for nearly six seconds. The plethora of honey that came after,
however, filled the jar completely in about half that time (1:30). Both Rabbit and Pooh observed both honey
transfers. The occasion with Gophur and
his pebble, however, was not visually observed: the company merely paused while
the stone announced its falling via slide whistle.
Ultimately, we
have three questions:
1) How does the observation of a falling object change
its speed?
2) Does the location of a fall (outside, underground,
into a honey pot) change the fall speed?
3) Do the laws of falling work the same for sentient
beings and inanimate objects?
An answer to all three questions (and hopefully more)
may just lie beyond the fourth wall, but it will take some careful examination
of detail to unravel them.
Firstly, let us return to the top of Gophur’s
hole. When he tested the depth with the
fateful pebble we observed his hole from the outside. However, his leap was shown from inside the hole (7:35). Besides his renewed sense of vigor, the only
change is our angle of observation. The
same is true with the honey jar situation:
The single drop fell when only the mouth of the jar was visible – the
deluge of honey came after we had a wider angle, showing the bottom of the jar
(from the outside - 1:30).
Happily, there is more evidence to work with on this
point. During their ball game, a curious
phenomenon overtakes the object in question.
The “ball” in the game “squishedball” appears to be a sock filled with
rice or beans and tied at the end.
During Piglet’s turn at bat, Tigger lobs the ball in a speedy
pitch. The ball leaves the screen almost
immediately after it leaves Tigger’s hand (1:57). We can see from a scene in the same episode
that Tigger is several times piglet’s size, and as such his shoulder (and the
initial point of his pitch) is higher that Piglet’s full stature (1:38). The next perspective is a view of Piglet,
being hit in the chest by the ball that appears to move from the ground up (1:57).
This pitch lifts him free of the base and into the air along the same
trajectory.
The angle we’re given offers a rather small window
into the playing field, so it is not unreasonable to see the ball pass through
the frame without changing its trajectory.
What is unreasonable, however, is that a pitch thrown by Tigger at his
stature should leave one frame horizontally and enter the next moving upward. Gravity pulls things down. So in the split second the ball was out of
our view, it changed both its position and its trajectory (see below):
This
is not to say Gravity has no place in the hundred acre wood. As we can see, this ball is moving rather
quickly, and we addressed the issue of gravity’s effects not being made
apparent in so small a window. Indeed,
in the next shot we can see Piglet’s flight path appear to level off – perhaps
the beginning of a parabolic curve, like the one traced by a normal trajectory
for a thrown object (at his velocity, though, there is no way to be sure). After he disappears beyond the horizon,
though, it becomes clear that his is no normal trajectory. A brief time later, Piglet appears from
beyond the horizon in the other direction, moving at the same speed and lands
(eighteen seconds after he left) in exactly the same spot.
Before we go further, there is one
small detail to note: although it appears the ball acquired both a new position
and velocity, we can only say definitively that the velocity changed. We can see that Piglet can be no more than a
Gopherheight tall, and that the ball hit him in the abdomen at an upward
angle. This goes to show that at the
start of the shot shown above, the ball was either on the ground or very close
to it. Now we reach an interesting
problem: could Tigger have thrown the ball such that it would reach that point
under normal conditions?
We can see that each base is about three Tiggerheights (another new unit, derived from Gophurheight) from the center of the pitcher’s mound (0:23). Tigger is more or less Christopher Robin’s height, which we have determined to be 120 cm. So the distance from the Tigger (on the mound) to Piglet (on base) is about 3.6 m. We also noted that the ball left Tigger’s hand with his arm outstretched, so we can consider its initial height to be around 1 m. We can plug this information into the formula we used previously to find the height of Rabbit’s fall and solve for t. Consequentially,
We can see that each base is about three Tiggerheights (another new unit, derived from Gophurheight) from the center of the pitcher’s mound (0:23). Tigger is more or less Christopher Robin’s height, which we have determined to be 120 cm. So the distance from the Tigger (on the mound) to Piglet (on base) is about 3.6 m. We also noted that the ball left Tigger’s hand with his arm outstretched, so we can consider its initial height to be around 1 m. We can plug this information into the formula we used previously to find the height of Rabbit’s fall and solve for t. Consequentially,
t = √(1m/4.905 m/s2)
= √(.2039 s2) = 0.452 s
We can now approach the problem two
different ways: time the interval
between when the ball left Tigger’s hand (about 0.5 seconds), or calculate the
velocity of the sock:
Vave
= Δd/Δt = 3.6m / 0.452s = 7.96 m/s
Comparing
either against the source material is difficult: timing half a second by hand
is bound to see some significant experimental error, but the same is true if we
use the brief window when the ball has left Tigger’s hand and is still on the
screen.
Ultimately,
we cannot rule out the possibility that the ball reached the position it did
naturally. As a result, we know that the
velocity of an object off-screen is subject to change, but cannot make a clear
judgment either way on the object’s position.
Now let us return to Piglet’s unusual
flight path. Given what we know about
the uncertainty of unobserved motion, we are called to wonder if there are any
other laws of physics being violated here – namely, the great speed limit. It is implied that he traveled around the
world, but did Piglet break the speed of light?
If
his position is subject to change off-screen as well as his velocity, there is
no reason to consider the point further: he might as well have jumped through a
wormhole (which, for all we know, could be the case). Technically he could have traversed a
distance in less time than a photon on a direct path would, but this is not the
same thing. A wormhole is a bend in
space – it does not mean he actually traveled faster than 3 x 108
m/s.
Assuming his velocity is the only
thing under threat of inconsistency, there are still multiple situations to
consider. Namely, if velocity is subject
to change, perhaps it can change in its direction without its magnitude being
affected. This means that after leaving
our line of sight, he could have traced a circular route around the field
before coming in for his landing. A
point of order: We know both can change – the ball Piglet was hit with is
clearly smaller than he is, yet it lifted him off the ground. Given its initial velocity 7.96 m/s, there is
no way after adding Piglet’s weight the combined mass traveled hundreds of feet
vertically and horizontally.
But just to be sure, let us suppose
Piglet traveled around the entire world.
For our needs, the earth can be considered a circle with radius 6,378
km. We will consider the added distance
from his height to be negligible. At
most, we probably saw 1 km of Piglet’s flight, so his path can be described as
D
= C – 1km = (2π)(6378km) – 1 km = 40,073 km
The
alteration only occurs when the object is not being observed by the
audience. Piglet was out of our field of
view for around 14 seconds, so that will be our time interval. Assuming a constant velocity for the duration
of his unobserved flight, we have
Vave
= Δd/Δt = 40,073,000m / 14s = 2.86 x 106 m/s
That’s
pretty fast. If this is the case, this
little piggy broke the sound barrier (and is about 80% of the current air speed
record), but he’s short of the speed of light by a factor of 100. So although the velocity can change, the
object in question is still subject to the rest of physics. For now.
Let us take one more look at the way
velocity is being affected in the Hundred Acre Wood. We have seen that the magnitude of a
projectile’s velocity changes sporadically, but only when that object is not
under direct observation by the audience.
Rabbit and Gophur have both survived falls from seemingly fatal heights,
indicating that speed can be decreased.
The Piglet/squishedball incident tells us that speed can also be
increased. Finally, the same
squishedball showed us that the direction of an object’s velocity can
change. However, Piglet’s observed
trajectory seems to indicate an object of variant path can still be affected by
gravity and, presumably, the rest of physics.
So does this coincide with the first principle of cartoon physics? We are unsure. We are also talking plurally.
We
have seen time and time again that objects at rest, even when off screen, will
stay at rest. Only when they have an
initial velocity are they subject to change.
However, every object has a position at all times, and therefore has an
initial position when off screen. This
implies that only velocity is manipulated, not position. The position obviously changes as a function
of that velocity, but there is no clear evidence the position is changing on
its own. So it would seem we can now
answer the three questions posited previously:
In
the Hundred Acre Wood, the velocity of an object (when not observed by the
audience) can change in any direction, and change in magnitude with a scalar
multiplier.
No comments:
Post a Comment